Timeline Albums, EPs & singles Songs Films Concerts Sessions People Interviews Articles

Monday, April 10, 1967

"Vega-Tables" session with The Beach Boys

For The Beach Boys

Last updated on May 12, 2024

Although the recording of the “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band” album was unfinished, Paul decided to take a ten-day break in the United States to surprise his girlfriend Jane Asher on her 21st birthday. The trip, which lasted from April 3 to April 11, 1967, was accompanied by Mal Evans.

On April 9, Paul and Mal travelled from Denver (where they had spent a few days with Jane) to Los Angeles, where they spent a couple of days.

On April 10, they went shopping before paying a visit to John and Michelle Phillips of The Mamas & The Papas. After a while, Paul left alone to join The Beach Boys at their recording session where he was recorded chewing vegetables for the song “Vega-Tables“, for their upcoming album “Smile“. He also played the guitar on an unrecorded rendition of the traditional song “On Top Of Old Smokey“.

Asked about his involvement in a 2001 interview, Paul said he had no memory of chomping vegetables at that session:

Brian Wilson: When he walked in, he had these beautiful patent leather shoes and a white suit… He looked so cool you know and we said “you want some vegetables?” We were cutting a song called “Vegetables”, we were all chewing on vegetables just to get the mood, and he started chewing on a carrot…

Paul McCartney: [Laugh] I don’t know, there might have been substances involved, it might have happened, I don’t know. I don’t remember it all, I must say, particularly some of those dark nights in LA… You know, you just sometimes would fall out of a car into a room, it would be very dark and I’m not sure if I remember it… I did visit a couple of those sessions but I don’t remember eating veggie, but I’m sure I might have.

From “McCartney” documentary by Robin Bextor, 2001

But in 2016, he offered a specific recollection:

Hi Paul, we’ve heard a story about you appearing on a Beach Boys song ‘playing’ a stick of celery. Is that true?

Yeah, that is true, yeah! I mean it was wild and wacky days, you know, and I just went round to the studio because they invited me. I just thought it would be fun to sit there and watch them record, ’cause I’m a big fan. And so I was there, and then it was, I think, Brian who came over and said, ‘Oh Paul, got a favour to ask: would you mind recording something?’ I thought, ‘Oh, no! But great, I could do that’. Oh God, I’m gonna be singing on a Beach Boys record or something, you know! I got a bit kind of intimidated and thought, ‘Okay, here goes nothing’. And they said, ‘Well, what we want you to do is go in there and just munch!’ …Well, I can do that! So, if you hear somebody munching celery, that’s me!”

Paul McCartney – From meatfreemondays.com, December 2016

Other participants in the session did remember Paul’s contribution:

The night before a big tour, I was out in the studio recording the vocal [for “Vegetables”] when, to my surprise, Paul McCartney walked in and joined Brian at the console. And, briefly, the two most influential musical Geminis in the world had a chance to work together.

Al Jardine – From the liner notes of “Smiley Smile / Wild Honey”

Paul came to the Vega-Tables session. Brian had some fresh vegetables out, for the mood. He sprinkled salt all over the console table near the mixing board and started dipping celery into the salt and chomping on it. Paul followed his lead and picked up the celery and did the same thing. It was priceless to see this.

Marilyn Wilson – first wife of Brian Wilson – From the liner notes of “The Smile Sessions (deluxe box”, Capitol Records, 2011

[…] Musical whims, as in Vega-Tables, where we had Paul McCartney come to the studio and crunch carrots with us. Paul even played the piano for me that night. I will never forget his white suit and red patent leather loafers.

Diane Rovell – Brian Wilson’s sister-in-law – From the liner notes of “The Smile Sessions (deluxe box”, Capitol Records, 2011

I was at the Beach Boys session for “Vega-Tables”, and Paul McCartney was there. We were in a booth, and we were supposed to shout out the names of vegetables. I was a young, punk kid at the time, and I shouted out ‘TV dinners!’ I didn’t know …

Rodney Bingenheimer – KROQ disck jockey – From “Smile : the story of Brian Wilson’s lost masterpiece“, 2007

It’s however unclear if Paul’s contribution was recorded. From Wikipedia:

On the existing tapes for these sessions, McCartney’s presence cannot be verified, and it is unclear if any record of his performance has survived. Archivist Craig Slowinski, who assembled the sessionography included with The Smile Sessions box set, stated: “I was ready to credit Sir Paul with ‘veggie munching’ … but since no tapes were found with his voice or reference to him, we figured I’d better not. Too hard to say that any veggie munching on his part remained on tape through the final stages of production.” Sessions co-producer Mark Linett explained: “Unless Paul is being very quiet, there’s no evidence that he’s a part of the chomping. And there’s quite a lot of discussion going on while that particular track is being recorded.


At some point in the session, Paul sat down and played “She’s Leaving Home“, which would be released a couple of months later on “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band”. He also played an acetate of “A Day In The Life“, also to be released on “Sgt. Pepper“.

[Paul] came in with Derek Taylor to a studio that we were in one night in 1967, and it was on that night that he played for my wife and I “She’s leaving home”. My wife cried and everyone was in tears, you know…

Brian Wilson – From “McCartney” documentary by Robin Bextor, 2001

Brian Wilson is reported to have heard the Beatles LP track “A Day In The Life Of”, and to be so knocked out that he has retired to live in a sauna bath, there to sweat out some more mind-jamming material for further Beach Boys discs.

From New Musical Express- Quoted in “Smile : the story of Brian Wilson’s lost masterpiece“, 2007

I remember waiting for long periods of time between takes to get to the next section or verse. Brian [seemed to have] lost track of the session. Paul would come on the talkback and say something like “Good take, Al.” Later, while I stayed in the booth listening to [my vocal work on] ‘Vegetables,’ Paul played the spectacular ‘A Day In The Life’ (from the as yet unreleased Sgt. Pepper LP). I’ll always regret [missing] that.”

Al Jardine – From the liner notes of “Smiley Smile / Wild Honey”

In the early hours of April 11, Paul left the session with Brian Wilson and went back to John and Michelle Phillips’ house, where they played some music together


Paul McCartney would chew more vegetables for The Super Furry Animals’ 2002 album “Rings Around The World“.


DEREK TAYLOR reporting from Hollywood on a meeting of the giants

PAUL drops in at a BEACH BOYS recording session

CHRISTMAS IN APRIL. PAUL McCARTNEY came to Los Angeles by stealth by night in FRANK SINATRA’S shimmering Lear Jet and was gone before half the city knew he’d been which is not to say he went unnoticed.

Word of mouth had him in every club on the Strip, with rumours of RINGO flying in a day later and GEORGE planning to follow with RAVI SHANKAR, but the reality was just Paul and dear old pal MALCOLM EVANS having a gentle 36 hours in LA (en route between Denver, Colorado and London).

Paul went to a BEACH BOYS session which is not something that happens to everyone who hits town nor is it something that happens to the Beach Boys every night nor is it every night the Beach Boys make a single.

They did when Paul was there though and maybe it was not an accident that it was finished that hothouse night. This single for which many of us long, not excepting the Beach Boys who would have chosen the word “ache” rather than “long” had they been writing this column as in a way they are, for there is no news this week more cheerful than the Beatle-Beach Boy rapport unless it be two meetings between Paul and PAPA MAMA, JOHN and MICHELLE with BYRDS CROSBY and McGUINN present at the first domestic encounter and BRIAN WILSON in attendance at the next.

Somehow it was like Van Gogh meeting Constable meeting Turner meeting Rembrandt in a time machine fuelled by a compound of adrenalin and dexedrine in un-equal parts depending on the necessary speed.

Paul in LA was as easy and open and settled as a child at play. He has, and not without conscious thoughts, reconstructed his attitudes to eliminate anger, intolerance, malice and spite (and as there was never any envy, greed, sloth, or hatred, nor was there any of the pressure which might induce lost).

Paul McCartney, free of any of the deadly sins, hopes with superb elan through a world which for the most part rejoices in his belonging to it. (The same goes for Mal Evans, a very beautiful product of an incomparable scene.)

Paul was very happy about the impending album; who can bear to wait to hear it? So little else bends the ear nor blows the mind as a Beatles LP. Parallel in the old days was the next episode of David Copperfield breathlessly anticipated from the English Channel to the Americas.

Any fine album is an adornment to one’s four-walled entrapment. The worst thing I heard anyone say last year came from an income tax collector I was trying to bribe with free albums, “No thank you,” he said, “I don’t have a record player in my home, you understand.”

Well, where were we vis-à-vis the Beach Roys? What I am really doing is stalling because I cannot find a facile way to tell you that the most famous single not to have been recorded is not yet recorded.

In other words, and to make the longest record ever made very short a tale, “Heroes and Vil-Iains” is not going to be a single. It is however going to make history as the one of ones that got away. The talk now is that it will be an album track on “Smile,” the also famous album also not yet complete.

Please understand that the Beach Boys delays with product are the result of painful self-criticism. The mirrors into which Brian Wilson looks for reassurance are not always kind. Sometimes there is no reflection at all. His view is that “Heroes and Villains,” at prevent, is tormented with over-elaboration and a score of second thoughts, cruelly chipped from his bump of caution. It was ever thus with great men.

Title of the new single “Vegetables” (the spelling may be wrong), a light and lyrical day-to-day green-grocery song on which AL JARDINE sings a most vigorous lead. The other side is wonderful which I only heard improvised at the piano with the boys humming the theme for Paul. At any rate, they will be ample samples of the best of The new Beach Boys stock-in-trade when next they come to Britain to show again why they were voted where they belong.

From Disc And Music Echo – April 22, 1967
From Disc And Music Echo – April 22, 1967

A Hard Day’s Surfin’ Safari

Brian Wilson & Paul McCartney met each other through music darkly and then face to face in my house and the first meeting was the easier because music is a more natural environment for a musicianly relationship than a living-room.

There had been, for many years, a mutually-warm admiration-society between the Beach Boys and the Beatles — an exchange of exultation at each other’s releases. The Beach Boys came first — they were formed in the schoolroom and their debut hit was in 1961, in the very week that the late Brian Epstein drew up his initial contract with the Beatles — and rhythm guitarist Al Jardine, (one of the founder-Beach Boys) recalls returning from a tour of Australia to find his country in the thrall of “I Want To Hold Your Hand” by the unknown Beatles.

Britain discovered the Beach Boys on a European TV and promotional trip in 1964 — the same year that America fell for the Beatles but the British response to the US group was an unworthy “Well, OK … so you’re the Beach Boys. We have our own home-grown scene going but thanks anyway…”

It was three years later, on the foaming tip of the crest of the tidal wave of “Pet Sounds” whipped to a fury by the gale of “Good Vibrations” that the Beach Boys swamped Britain and the rest of Europe with such a flood of success that in London’s “New Musical Express” voters decided the American group should replace the Beatles as “Top World Group.”

During the years between “Surfin Safari” and “Revolver” Lennon/McCartney and Wilson watched the development of each group’s work with increasing interest and with — so musical people tell me — substantial influence on each other’s experimentation. A long time ago, Lennon commented in print that “Wilson was a bloody genius who uses voices like instruments” and Wilson, for his part, freely conceded that it was the critical acclaim accorded “Rubber Soul” that had spurred him to reach a new plateau with “Pet Sounds,” a climb, which though Beatle-inspired, did not tempt him to use their footholds, steal their guidelines nor filch any of their deft short-cuts. Why should he? He had enough of his own.

I had left the Beatles before “Rubber Soul” and had joined the Beach Boys at “Pet Sounds” time and there were moments when I sensed the unspoken “Mirror, mirror on the wall; who is the fairest of us all?” But apart from conversational slips of the tongue, which may have been Freudian or simply phonetic — “Beach Boys” sometimes came, out as “Beatles” or vice versa — I managed to steer a course in representing the Californian fivesome which took me safely along the narrow road from Beatle Friendship to Beach Boys Loyalty, twin townships in which there were signs of incipient rivalry.

Some members of the groups had met on the road in 1965, somewhere in. the North West where the tours coincided. But the meeting had been one of those scrambling handshakescenes in a dressing-room physically inadequate to accommodate a duo of dwarfs, let alone two man-sized rock ’n roll groups with Fenders, Rickenbackers, Gibsons, practice amps, cops, bouncers, promoters, boxes of fanmail, and piled up trays of halfchewed hamburgers.

Against such clutter there had been, therefore, little real rapport and in any case, Brian Wilson was not around at the meeting.

A year later, however, after “Pet Sounds” and before “Revolver”—is it not strange how one measures history in albums, yet not so strange as measurement in wars — it became clear that a summit of some sort was timely and meaningful. So when the Beatles came to Los Angeles in 1966 for the last-but-one concert in their lovingly-remembered live career, I created a domestic climate in which composer might collide with composer and communicate without harrassment or pain.

Paul was first to arrive, in the best of humor. Brian Wilson called, Paul took the call and said “come on over” and Brian did, with brother Carl and their wives.

The lights were low in the house and the Los Angeles basin twinkled blue, red gold and silver and we had “Glenn Miller’s Latest Hits” softly on the record player. “Hi” said Brian and the Wilsons. “Hello” said Paul and added: “Well you’re Brian Wilson and I’m Paul McCartney so let’s get that out of the way and have a good time.” Brian laughed and said “Would you like to hear a dub?”

He played the extraordinarily fascinating track of “Good Vibrations” and it impressed Paul who asked for the dub “as a souvenir.” Brian said he’d rather not part with it. He wasn’t completely happy with the sound. Oh well. It didn’t matter that much.

We talked for a couple of hours, joined by David Crosby of the Byrds and by George Harrison. It wasn’t a bad meeting but it wasn’t the answer. Paul and Brian knew that and I did too.

Thus, in the spring of this year, when Paul returned as a “private citizen” to LA we decided to do the meeting again — this time in a recording studio. I took Paul to Sound Recorders in Hollywood and this time a real bond was formed between the Englishman and the American — a bond which will not readily become unsealed. Brian was at his most active and energetic as producer that night and it was a fine three-hour music involvement.

The record under production was “Vegetables,” then planned as a single now to be an album track on “Smiley Smile,” the Beach Boys next album — the first LP to be released on the Brother Records label distributed through CAPITOL.

Capitol. CAPITOL!

Capitol is where I should have come in for this labyrinthian narrative intertwining the Beatles with the Beach Boys was asked of me by Cash Box to celebrate Capitol’s birthday but I left the connection until the end because it seemed more graceful.

However, I cannot see that the fact of Capitol’s continuing to keep the Beach Boys and the Beatles as signed artists is a coincidence for there is nothing coincidental in competitive commerce. After all, the Beatles entered America on VeeJay and the Beach Boys did not start on Capitol but on something called “Candix” and also, of course, the group and Capitol has only recently emerged (emotionally unharmed) from a lawsuit instigated by the Beach Boys against the label.

I cannot say what it is Capitol has to offer the two groups for a record label is many things to many people but whatever Capitol represents as a company, it must be worthy and valuable for the Beatles have re-signed with them for something like nine years and the Beach Boys are — despite their new Brother Records family front — still in business with Capitol.

Derek Taylor – From Cashbox – September 16, 1967
From Cashbox – September 16, 1967

Session activities

  1. Vega-Tables

    Written by Brian Wilson, Van Dyke Parks

    Recording

  2. On Top of Old Smokey

    Written by Traditional

    Recording


Staff

Musicians

Visitors


Going further

If we modestly consider the Paul McCartney Project to be the premier online resource for all things Paul McCartney, it is undeniable that The Beatles Bible stands as the definitive online site dedicated to the Beatles. While there is some overlap in content between the two sites, they differ significantly in their approach.

Read more on The Beatles Bible

Paul McCartney writing

Talk more talk, chat more chat

Notice any inaccuracies on this page? Have additional insights or ideas for new content? Or just want to share your thoughts? We value your feedback! Please use the form below to get in touch with us.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

2024 • Please note this site is strictly non-commercial. All pictures, videos & quoted texts remain the property of the respective copyright owner, and no implication of ownership by us is intended or should be inferred. Any copyright owner who wants something removed should contact us and we will do so immediately. Alternatively, we would be delighted to provide credits.