Official album • Released in 1995
1:46 • Demo • C • [...] this 3 June demo recording of the song certainly has not been heard before. It was announced at the time that John was giving No Reply to Tommy Quickly, another of Brian Epstein's artists, and - as John sings it in a staccato, jaunty style more typical of Quickly's than his own - it's feasible that this demo was recorded with that donation in mind. (All the same, if he recorded it all, quickly never issued his version.) Intriguingly, a drummer is evident, even though no recognised player - neither Ringo nor Jimmy Nicol - was present.
George Martin : Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer
Session Recording: Jun 03, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Official album • Released in 1995
2:29 • Outtake • D • Take 2. Almost four months after the song had been recorded in demo form, the Beatles returned to No Reply and taped a definitive version, Take 8, for Beatles For Sale. Presented here, as balance engineer Norman Smith announced, is Take 2, unreleased, which underlines the more dramatic, bluesy style that John perhaps meant for his song. Laughter ensured that this particular take could not have been used, but it was clearly an important stepping-stone to the master version, John concluding "Well, we just found out what to do, anyway - it's good!"
George Martin : Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Streaming • Released in 2016
1:46 • Demo • C2016 • [...] this 3 June demo recording of the song certainly has not been heard before. It was announced at the time that John was giving No Reply to Tommy Quickly, another of Brian Epstein's artists, and - as John sings it in a staccato, jaunty style more typical of Quickly's than his own - it's feasible that this demo was recorded with that donation in mind. (All the same, if he recorded it all, quickly never issued his version.) Intriguingly, a drummer is evident, even though no recognised player - neither Ringo nor Jimmy Nicol - was present.
George Martin : Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer
Session Recording: Jun 03, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Streaming • Released in 2016
2:29 • Outtake • D2016 • Take 2. Almost four months after the song had been recorded in demo form, the Beatles returned to No Reply and taped a definitive version, Take 8, for Beatles For Sale. Presented here, as balance engineer Norman Smith announced, is Take 2, unreleased, which underlines the more dramatic, bluesy style that John perhaps meant for his song. Laughter ensured that this particular take could not have been used, but it was clearly an important stepping-stone to the master version, John concluding "Well, we just found out what to do, anyway - it's good!"
George Martin : Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Official album • Released in 2004
2:15 • Studio version • B2004 • Stereo • 2004 remaster
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer Ted Jensen : Remastering
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Nov 04, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Official album • Released in 2004
2:15 • Studio version • A2004 • Mono • 2004 remaster
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer Ted Jensen : Remastering
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Oct 16, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Official album • Released in 2014
2:15 • Studio version • A2009 • Mono • 2009 remaster
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer Paul Hicks : Remastering Guy Massey : Remastering Sean Magee : Remastering Allan Rouse : Project co-ordinator
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Oct 16, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Official album • Released in 2014
2:15 • Studio version • B2009 • Stereo • 2009 remaster
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer Guy Massey : Remastering Steve Rooke : Remastering Allan Rouse : Project co-ordinator
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Nov 04, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
LP • Released in 2024
2:15 • Studio version • A • Mono
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Oct 16, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
LP • Released in 1964
2:15 • Studio version • A • Mono
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Oct 16, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Official album • Released in 1964
2:15 • Studio version • B • Stereo
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Nov 04, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
EP • Released in 1965
2:20 • Studio version • A
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Oct 16, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles for Sale (Mono - 2009 remaster)
Official album • Released in 2009
2:15 • Studio version • A2009 • Mono • 2009 mono remaster
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer Paul Hicks : Remastering Guy Massey : Remastering Sean Magee : Remastering Allan Rouse : Project co-ordinator
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Oct 16, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles For Sale (Mono - 2014 vinyl)
LP • Released in 2014
2:15 • Studio version • A2014 • Mono • 2014 remaster
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer Sean Magee : Remastering Steve Berkowitz : Remastering
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Oct 16, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
LP • Released in 1964
2:15 • Studio version • A • Mono
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Oct 16, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles for Sale (Stereo - 2009 remaster)
Official album • Released in 2009
2:15 • Studio version • B2009 • Stereo • 2009 stereo remaster
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer Guy Massey : Remastering Steve Rooke : Remastering Allan Rouse : Project co-ordinator
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Nov 04, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
LP • Released in 1964
2:15 • Studio version • B • Stereo
Paul McCartney : Bass, Handclaps, Harmony vocals Ringo Starr : Drums, Handclaps John Lennon : Acoustic rhythm guitar, Handclaps, Vocals George Harrison : Handclaps, Rhythm guitar George Martin : Piano, Producer Norman Smith : Recording engineer
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Session Mixing: Nov 04, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles For Sale - Studio Sessions - Back To Basics
Unofficial album • Released in 2011
0:42 • Alternate take • Stereo • Take 1 Stereo
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles For Sale - Studio Sessions - Back To Basics
Unofficial album • Released in 2011
2:28 • Alternate take • Mono • Take 2 Mono
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles For Sale - Studio Sessions - Back To Basics
Unofficial album • Released in 2011
0:42 • Alternate take • Mono • Take 1 - Clean VHS mix
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles For Sale - Studio Sessions - Back To Basics
Unofficial album • Released in 2011
0:10 • Alternate take • Stereo • Unknown partial take 1 - Stereo
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles For Sale - Studio Sessions - Back To Basics
Unofficial album • Released in 2011
0:12 • Alternate take • Mono • Unknown partial take 2 - Mono
Session Recording: Sep 30, 1964 • Studio EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road